Best Electric Crate Motors for Effortless Swaps

Remember that beat-up classic car sitting in your garage, gathering dust and memories? Maybe it’s a ’67 Mustang, a vintage VW Beetle, or even a beloved old pickup truck. You love the look, the feel, and the history, but the engine? Let’s just say it’s seen better days. For years, you’ve dreamt of bringing it back to life, modernizing it for the 21st century, and turning heads as you cruise down the street. Now, thanks to the growing popularity of electric vehicle technology, that dream is closer than ever. What if you could swap that gas-guzzling engine for a clean, powerful, and reliable electric motor? This is where the discussion on the best electric crate motors begins.

The world of electric vehicle conversions is rapidly evolving, and choosing the right components can be overwhelming. So, how do you find the perfect electric heart for your project car? Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered! In this comprehensive guide, we’ll dive into the exciting world of the best electric crate motors, exploring the top options available, their key features, and the factors you need to consider before making your purchase. Get ready to electrify your ride and experience the thrill of classic style with modern electric power!

Before we jump into the best electric crate motors review, let’s take a look at these Amazon products:

Last update on 2025-05-04 / Affiliate links / #CommissionsEarned / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Table of Contents

The Spark is Back: A Beginner’s Guide to Electric Crate Motors

So, you’re thinking about electrifying your ride? Awesome! Whether you’re dreaming of silent cruising in your classic muscle car or giving your beloved truck a zero-emission makeover, swapping in an electric motor is becoming increasingly popular. It’s not just about being eco-conscious, though – it’s about unlocking a whole new level of performance and reliability. Let’s face it, the idea of ditching the complexities of a traditional internal combustion engine for the smooth, instant torque of electric power is pretty darn appealing.

Now, you might be asking, “What exactly is an electric crate motor?” Think of it as a ready-to-install electric powertrain, complete with a motor, inverter, and often a battery pack, designed to replace your existing engine. It’s similar to the concept of swapping a traditional V8, but with electrons instead of gasoline. The market is still relatively young, but growing fast. Industry analysts predict the electric crate motor market will see significant expansion in the coming years, driven by both DIY enthusiasts and professional custom builders.

Choosing the best electric crate motors for your project can feel overwhelming at first. There are different voltage levels, power outputs, battery options, and compatibility considerations to navigate. You’ll want to think about your budget, desired performance, and the vehicle you’re electrifying. Are you looking for a budget-friendly option for a small vintage car, or are you aiming for neck-snapping acceleration in a modern sports car?

In this guide, we’re going to break down the options, explore some of the top players in the electric crate motor game, and help you understand what to look for when making your decision. We’ll delve into the key features, performance metrics, and real-world applications, so you can confidently choose the best electric crate motors to bring your electric dream to life. Get ready to plug in and power up!

Best Electric Crate Motors – Reviews

Chevrolet Performance Electric Connect and Cruise eCrate Motor

The Chevrolet Performance Electric Connect and Cruise eCrate Motor really stands out for its comprehensive package. It’s not just an electric motor; it’s a whole system designed to seamlessly integrate into your classic or custom build. Think about it – you get the motor, battery pack, controllers, and all the necessary wiring and software. Chevy has done a great job of taking the guesswork out of the EV conversion process, making it accessible to a wider range of enthusiasts.

What’s truly impressive is the level of engineering that has gone into this crate motor. It’s designed to deliver reliable performance and good range, and they provide extensive support. While the price point might be higher than some standalone motors, the value lies in the complete system integration and the peace of mind that comes with knowing you’re using components designed to work together. It’s a great option for those looking for a polished, well-supported EV conversion.

Ford Performance Eluminator eCrate Motor

The Ford Performance Eluminator eCrate Motor is making waves in the EV conversion scene, particularly for Ford enthusiasts. It’s a powerful and compact motor designed to slot into a variety of vehicles, and it boasts impressive performance figures. Imagine dropping this into a classic Mustang – the possibilities are exciting! The motor itself is robust and well-engineered, reflecting Ford’s commitment to electric technology.

One of the biggest selling points is its modularity. You can easily combine multiple Eluminator motors to create a high-performance, all-wheel-drive EV. This opens up a world of customization and allows you to tailor the power output to your specific needs. While you’ll need to source the battery pack and controller separately, the Eluminator’s versatility and readily available support make it a fantastic choice for a wide range of EV projects.

Tesla Model 3 Drive Unit

The Tesla Model 3 Drive Unit has become a popular option for EV conversions thanks to its readily available supply and impressive performance-to-price ratio. These units are salvaged from used Model 3 vehicles, making them a more affordable alternative to brand-new crate motors. Don’t let the “salvaged” aspect fool you, though; these motors are known for their robust construction and impressive power output.

Because these are pulled from existing vehicles, integration can be more complex than a purpose-built crate motor. You’ll need to figure out the battery management system, cooling, and other essential components. However, the vibrant community surrounding Tesla swaps means there are plenty of resources and aftermarket solutions available to help you along the way. If you’re looking for a powerful and relatively affordable EV motor and aren’t afraid of a bit of a challenge, the Model 3 Drive Unit is a solid choice.

Hyper 9 IS Electric Motor

The Hyper 9 IS electric motor is a favorite among DIY enthusiasts and professional builders alike. It’s known for its compact size, high power density, and affordability. This motor packs a serious punch for its weight, making it ideal for smaller vehicles or those seeking a lightweight EV conversion.

What really sets the Hyper 9 apart is its versatility. It can be configured for a wide range of voltages and power outputs, allowing you to tailor it to your specific needs. Plus, it’s compatible with a variety of controllers and battery systems, giving you even more flexibility in your build. Whether you’re converting a classic Mini or building a custom electric go-kart, the Hyper 9 is a reliable and powerful option.

Cascadia Motion PM150DZ Inverter and Motor

The Cascadia Motion PM150DZ Inverter and Motor are for those serious about high-performance electric vehicles. This is an industrial-grade solution designed for demanding applications like racing and heavy-duty vehicles. This isn’t your average EV motor; it’s built to withstand extreme conditions and deliver consistent, reliable power.

What makes the PM150DZ truly exceptional is its advanced inverter technology. It allows for precise control over the motor, resulting in smooth acceleration, responsive handling, and maximum efficiency. While the price point reflects its high-end capabilities, the PM150DZ is an investment in performance and durability. If you’re building a no-compromise electric vehicle and demand the best, this is a top contender.

Why Buy an Electric Crate Motor?

Imagine your beloved classic car, sitting patiently in the garage, yearning for the open road. But every trip is a compromise – the rumble of the engine you love is accompanied by concerns about emissions, fuel costs, and potential breakdowns of aging parts. Or picture yourself as an avid off-roader, seeking silent adventures in nature without disrupting the peace with a roaring combustion engine. An electric crate motor offers a solution: a way to breathe new, sustainable life into your favorite vehicle, combining the nostalgia and style you cherish with the performance and efficiency of modern electric technology.

The beauty of an electric crate motor lies in its versatility. Whether you’re restoring a vintage pickup, converting a muscle car, or building a custom off-road buggy, the best electric crate motors offer a clean, powerful, and reliable alternative to traditional engines. Think of the instant torque, the reduced maintenance (no more oil changes!), and the significant decrease in your carbon footprint. It’s like giving your car a second life, one powered by the future.

Beyond the environmental benefits and reduced running costs, electric crate motors offer a unique driving experience. The silent acceleration and smooth power delivery are simply exhilarating. And with advancements in battery technology, the best electric crate motors are now capable of impressive range, making those long drives more than just a pipe dream. Imagine cruising down the highway in your classic car, the only sound the gentle hum of the electric motor, knowing you’re contributing to a cleaner, greener future.

Ultimately, investing in an electric crate motor is about more than just swapping out an engine. It’s about embracing innovation, preserving automotive history, and creating a personalized driving experience that aligns with your values. It’s about future-proofing your passion and enjoying the best of both worlds: the timeless appeal of your favorite vehicle and the cutting-edge technology of electric power. The best electric crate motors are not just a purchase, they are an investment in a more sustainable, exciting, and personalized automotive future.

Understanding Electric Motor Terminology

Ever felt lost in a sea of technical jargon when researching electric motors? You’re not alone! Understanding the basics can make a huge difference when choosing the right electric crate motor for your project. Think of it like learning a new language – once you grasp the key vocabulary, everything else starts to fall into place.

Let’s start with “torque.” This is the twisting force an electric motor produces, basically the “muscle” that turns your wheels or powers your machinery. A motor with high torque can handle heavier loads and steeper inclines, making it ideal for applications like off-road vehicles or industrial equipment. Think about it like this: a small motor might be able to spin quickly (high RPM), but lack the muscle to move a heavy car.

Then there’s “RPM,” or Revolutions Per Minute. This tells you how fast the motor’s shaft is spinning. Higher RPM typically translates to higher speed, but it’s also important to consider torque. A balance between torque and RPM is key to achieving optimal performance for your specific application. Imagine a drag race car – it needs both high RPM to reach top speed and high torque to accelerate quickly off the starting line.

Finally, consider “Voltage” and “Amperage.” Voltage is the electrical pressure pushing the current, while amperage is the amount of current flowing. These two factors determine the power output of the motor. Making sure your motor and battery system match voltage and amperage needs is crucial for safe and efficient operation, preventing damage and ensuring the motor performs as expected. It’s similar to making sure you are using the right outlet for a new appliance – too little voltage, and it won’t work; too much, and you risk frying it!

Cost Considerations and ROI

Let’s be honest, electric crate motors can represent a significant investment upfront. However, looking at the long-term cost benefits can paint a very different picture. Think of it like solar panels – the initial cost may seem daunting, but the long-term savings on electricity bills can be substantial. Similarly, electric motors can offer compelling return on investment.

One major factor is reduced maintenance. Electric motors have far fewer moving parts than internal combustion engines, translating to less frequent maintenance and lower repair costs. No more oil changes, spark plug replacements, or exhaust system repairs! Imagine the time and money saved by eliminating these routine tasks – it can really add up over the lifespan of the motor.

Fuel costs are another huge consideration. Electricity is often cheaper than gasoline or diesel, and electric motors are significantly more efficient at converting energy into motion. This means you can travel farther and work harder for less money. Think about the difference in cost between filling up a gas tank and charging a battery – the savings can be dramatic, especially for applications with high mileage or usage.

Finally, consider government incentives and tax credits. Many regions offer financial incentives to encourage the adoption of electric vehicles and equipment. These incentives can significantly reduce the initial cost of an electric crate motor, making it an even more attractive investment. Check your local and federal regulations to see what kind of savings you could be eligible for – it could be the deciding factor in making the switch.

Installation Tips and Tricks

Installing an electric crate motor might seem intimidating, but with the right preparation and knowledge, it can be a manageable project. Think of it like installing a new appliance – following the instructions carefully and double-checking your connections are key to success. Here are a few tips and tricks to make the process smoother.

First, thoroughly review the manufacturer’s instructions. Each electric crate motor is different, and the installation process can vary depending on the model and your specific application. Understanding the instructions inside and out will help you avoid mistakes and ensure a safe and successful installation. Don’t be afraid to contact the manufacturer’s support team if you have any questions or concerns.

Second, take your time and plan ahead. Rushing the installation can lead to errors and potentially damage the motor or your vehicle. Before you even start, gather all the necessary tools and materials, and familiarize yourself with the wiring diagrams. A well-organized workspace and a methodical approach will make the process much easier and less stressful.

Third, pay close attention to wiring and connections. Proper wiring is crucial for safe and efficient operation. Use the correct gauge wires and ensure all connections are secure and properly insulated. A loose connection can cause voltage drops, overheating, and even damage to the motor. Double-check your connections with a multimeter to ensure everything is wired correctly before powering on the system.

Finally, consider seeking professional help if you’re not comfortable with any aspect of the installation. A qualified electrician or mechanic can provide expert guidance and ensure the job is done correctly. Even if you’re comfortable doing most of the work yourself, it might be worth consulting a professional for complex tasks like wiring the motor controller or integrating the motor into your existing vehicle system.

Electric Crate Motor Applications Beyond Cars

While electric crate motors are often associated with converting cars to electric, their applications extend far beyond just vehicles. Think of them as versatile power sources that can be adapted to a wide range of uses, opening up exciting possibilities in various industries and even for personal projects.

One popular application is in the marine industry. Electric crate motors can be used to power boats, providing a clean and quiet alternative to traditional combustion engines. Electric boats are becoming increasingly popular for recreational use, offering a smooth and silent ride that enhances the boating experience. Imagine gliding across the water without the noise and fumes of a gas-powered engine – it’s a truly peaceful and enjoyable experience.

Electric crate motors are also finding their way into industrial equipment. From forklifts and cranes to pumps and compressors, electric motors offer significant advantages in terms of efficiency, maintenance, and environmental impact. Electric forklifts, for example, are becoming increasingly common in warehouses and factories, providing a cleaner and quieter alternative to diesel-powered models. This not only improves air quality for workers but also reduces noise pollution in the workplace.

Beyond industrial and marine applications, electric crate motors are being used in a variety of unique and innovative projects. They can be used to power electric bicycles, scooters, and even small aircraft. Hobbyists and inventors are also experimenting with electric motors for robotics, automation, and other DIY projects. Think of the possibilities – you could use an electric crate motor to build your own electric go-kart, power a remote-controlled airplane, or create a self-sufficient off-grid power system.

Best Electric Crate Motors: A Buyer’s Guide to Powering Your Dream Ride

So, you’re thinking about electrifying your ride with an electric crate motor? Awesome! You’re about to embark on a journey that blends classic car passion with cutting-edge technology. Swapping a gasoline engine for an electric powertrain can bring your vintage beauty into the 21st century, boost performance, and drastically reduce your carbon footprint. But with so many options popping up, navigating the world of electric crate motors can feel a little overwhelming. Don’t worry, consider me your friendly guide. Let’s break down the essential factors you need to consider to make sure you choose the best electric crate motors for your specific needs and dreams.

Power and Performance: Finding the Right Zap for Your Ride

First things first, let’s talk about power. This is where the rubber meets the road, literally! You need to figure out how much oomph you want your electric motor to deliver. Are you aiming for exhilarating acceleration and thrilling top speeds, or are you prioritizing efficiency and a more relaxed driving experience? The power output of an electric crate motor is usually measured in horsepower (hp) and torque (lb-ft or Nm). Consider the original power of the engine you’re replacing and whether you want to match it, exceed it, or opt for something more modest.

Think about your vehicle’s intended use. Is it a daily driver, a weekend cruiser, or a track-day demon? A classic muscle car destined for the drag strip will demand a much more potent motor than a vintage Beetle intended for leisurely Sunday drives. Don’t get caught up in chasing the highest numbers just for bragging rights; a well-matched motor will provide a more enjoyable and usable driving experience. Selecting the best electric crate motors depends on your goals for the vehicle.

Battery Capacity and Range: Going the Distance on Electrons

Next up is battery capacity, the energy reservoir that fuels your electric adventures. The battery’s size, measured in kilowatt-hours (kWh), directly impacts how far you can drive on a single charge. Range anxiety is real, so you need to carefully consider your driving habits and typical distances. Do you primarily make short trips around town, or do you frequently embark on longer journeys? A larger battery pack will offer greater range, but it will also increase the cost and weight of your conversion.

Don’t forget to factor in driving conditions. Things like weather and terrain can significantly impact your vehicle’s range. Driving in cold weather or climbing steep hills will drain the battery faster than cruising on a flat highway in mild temperatures. Research the typical range offered by different electric crate motor systems and compare it to your needs. Keep in mind that advertised ranges are often based on ideal conditions, so it’s wise to add a buffer. The best electric crate motors provide a balance of range and efficiency, catering to both daily commutes and occasional road trips.

Voltage and Compatibility: Making Sure Everything Plays Nice Together

Voltage is like the electrical language that your motor and battery speak. Choosing a system with the wrong voltage can lead to all sorts of problems, from reduced performance to outright failure. Electric crate motor systems typically operate at higher voltages than traditional 12-volt systems, so you’ll need to ensure that all components are compatible with the chosen voltage.

Furthermore, compatibility extends beyond just the voltage. You’ll need to consider the physical dimensions of the motor and battery pack to ensure they fit within your vehicle’s chassis. Check for any clearance issues with existing components, such as suspension parts or exhaust systems (or, well, where the exhaust system used to be!). Some electric crate motor manufacturers offer universal kits designed for a wide range of vehicles, while others specialize in specific models. Do your research to make sure the motor and battery will physically integrate with your vehicle, and that any necessary adapters or mounting hardware are available. The best electric crate motors will be designed to integrate seamlessly into your classic car.

Cooling System: Keeping Your Motor from Overheating

Electric motors, like their gasoline counterparts, generate heat. And too much heat is never a good thing. That’s where the cooling system comes in. A robust cooling system is crucial for maintaining optimal motor performance and extending its lifespan. Most electric crate motor systems use liquid cooling, circulating coolant through the motor and battery pack to dissipate heat.

Consider the efficiency of the cooling system and its ability to handle high-load conditions. If you plan on pushing your electric motor to its limits, such as during spirited driving or track days, you’ll need a more robust cooling system. Look for systems with larger radiators, more powerful pumps, and efficient heat exchangers. Some manufacturers even offer active cooling systems that automatically adjust cooling based on temperature. Proper cooling is essential for preserving the longevity of the best electric crate motors.

Regenerative Braking: Capturing Energy and Extending Range

Regenerative braking is one of the coolest features of electric vehicles. It allows the motor to act as a generator during deceleration, converting kinetic energy back into electrical energy and storing it in the battery. This not only helps to extend your range but also reduces wear on your brake pads.

The effectiveness of regenerative braking can vary depending on the system. Some systems offer adjustable levels of regenerative braking, allowing you to tailor the driving experience to your preferences. A strong regenerative braking system can significantly improve your overall efficiency and reduce your reliance on traditional friction brakes. This is especially beneficial in stop-and-go traffic, where regenerative braking can capture a significant amount of energy. Seek out the best electric crate motors that have efficient and adjustable regenerative braking.

Controller and Software: The Brains Behind the Operation

The controller and software are the brains of your electric crate motor system. The controller manages the flow of electricity between the battery, motor, and other components. The software governs the motor’s performance, including acceleration, torque delivery, and regenerative braking. A well-designed controller and software package is essential for optimal performance and reliability.

Look for systems with user-friendly interfaces that allow you to monitor the motor’s performance and adjust settings as needed. Some controllers offer advanced features such as traction control, launch control, and customizable driving modes. Ensure that the software is regularly updated to address any bugs or improve performance. A responsive and intuitive controller will allow you to unlock the full potential of your electric motor. This means paying attention to the tuning options available in the software package, which are a crucial element of the best electric crate motors.

Cost and Installation: Budgeting for Electrification

Last but certainly not least, let’s talk about cost. Electrifying your ride is an investment, and it’s essential to have a realistic budget in mind. Electric crate motor systems can range in price from a few thousand dollars to tens of thousands of dollars, depending on the power, battery capacity, and features. Don’t just focus on the initial purchase price; consider the total cost of ownership, including installation, maintenance, and electricity costs.

Installation can be a significant expense, depending on your skill level and the complexity of the conversion. Unless you’re a highly experienced mechanic with expertise in electrical systems, it’s best to hire a professional to handle the installation. Get quotes from multiple installers and factor in the cost of any necessary modifications to your vehicle. A well-planned and professionally installed system will ensure that your investment is protected and that your electric conversion is a success. The best electric crate motors will have great support for professional installers, and some even have certified installers in your area.

Frequently Asked Questions

What exactly *is* an electric crate motor, and why would I want one?

Think of an electric crate motor as a complete, ready-to-install electric powertrain. Just like a gasoline crate engine, it’s designed to be a self-contained unit that you can drop into a vehicle. Instead of a combustion engine, though, you get an electric motor, inverter, and often a battery management system, all pre-configured and tested. It’s a shortcut to EV conversion!

Why would you want one? Well, if you’re dreaming of turning your classic car into a zero-emission vehicle, giving your off-road rig a silent and torquey upgrade, or even building a custom electric vehicle from scratch, an electric crate motor is your best friend. They simplify the whole process, taking away a lot of the guesswork and technical hurdles normally associated with EV conversions.

How difficult is it to install an electric crate motor? Do I need to be a professional mechanic?

Installation difficulty really depends on a few factors: your mechanical skills, the complexity of the crate motor kit, and the vehicle you’re installing it into. Some kits are designed for relatively straightforward swaps, while others might require more extensive modifications. Honestly, if you’re comfortable with basic automotive work, like engine swaps and wiring, you might be able to tackle it yourself.

However, because you’re dealing with high-voltage electricity, it’s wise to consider getting help from a professional experienced in EV conversions. They can ensure everything is wired correctly, grounded safely, and properly integrated with your vehicle’s systems. It’s better to be safe than sorry when electricity is involved! Even if you do most of the work yourself, having a pro double-check everything can give you peace of mind.

What kind of range can I expect from an electric crate motor conversion?

Range is the big question, isn’t it? The range you’ll get from your electric crate motor conversion depends heavily on the battery pack you choose. Different kits offer various battery options, and the bigger the battery capacity (measured in kilowatt-hours, or kWh), the farther you’ll be able to drive. Also, the weight and aerodynamics of your vehicle will impact range; a heavy SUV will naturally have less range than a lightweight sports car with the same battery.

Beyond the battery, driving habits play a role too. Just like with a gasoline car, aggressive acceleration and high speeds will drain the battery faster. Many manufacturers will provide estimated range figures for their kits, but remember those are usually based on ideal conditions. Expect real-world range to be a bit lower, but with careful planning and the right battery pack, you can definitely achieve a practical range for your needs.

How much does an electric crate motor conversion typically cost?

Let’s be real, electric crate motor conversions aren’t exactly cheap. The initial cost can be significant, especially when you factor in the crate motor itself, the battery pack, and any supporting components. On top of that, you’ll likely need to factor in the cost of installation, whether you do it yourself or hire a professional.

However, it’s also worth considering the long-term savings. Electric vehicles typically have lower running costs than gasoline cars. You’ll save on fuel, of course, and you’ll likely have lower maintenance costs too, as EVs have fewer moving parts. Plus, depending on where you live, you might be eligible for government incentives or tax credits that can help offset the initial investment. So, while the upfront cost can be a hurdle, think of it as an investment in a cleaner, more efficient future.

Are electric crate motors reliable? What kind of maintenance is involved?

Generally, electric motors are known for their reliability. They have far fewer moving parts than internal combustion engines, which means there are fewer things that can break down. Electric crate motors are also typically designed and tested to withstand the rigors of automotive use.

As for maintenance, you’ll still need to take care of things like brakes, tires, and suspension. However, you can say goodbye to oil changes, spark plug replacements, and all the other routine maintenance tasks associated with gasoline engines. The main maintenance item for an electric crate motor is keeping the battery pack healthy, which usually involves proper charging habits and occasionally checking the coolant levels (if the battery pack is liquid-cooled).

What about charging? How long does it take to charge an electric crate motor conversion?

Charging time is another important consideration. It depends on the size of your battery pack and the type of charging you’re using. A standard 120V outlet (Level 1 charging) will charge your battery very slowly, perhaps adding only a few miles of range per hour. A 240V outlet (Level 2 charging), which is what most EV owners install at home, is much faster, potentially fully charging your battery overnight.

The fastest charging method is DC fast charging (Level 3 charging), which you’ll find at public charging stations. This can add significant range in a relatively short amount of time, often in less than an hour. Keep in mind that charging speed also depends on the maximum charging rate of your battery pack; some packs can accept higher charging rates than others.

Will an electric crate motor affect my car’s resale value?

That’s a tricky question! The resale value of a car with an electric crate motor conversion can be a bit of a wild card. On one hand, you’ve added a unique and desirable feature, especially in a market that’s increasingly interested in electric vehicles. This could attract buyers who are specifically looking for a classic car with modern EV technology.

On the other hand, some buyers might prefer the original, unmodified version of your car. Plus, the value could depend on the quality of the conversion, the reputation of the crate motor manufacturer, and the overall condition of the vehicle. While it’s hard to say for sure how it will affect resale value, a well-executed and documented conversion could definitely make your car stand out and potentially increase its value to the right buyer.

Final Thoughts

So, there you have it! Your journey into the electrifying world of the best electric crate motors is complete. You’re now armed with the knowledge to confidently navigate the market, understand the key features, and choose the perfect motor for your dream project. Remember, the future of automotive is electric, and you’re now ready to be a part of that revolution. Whether you’re looking for raw power, efficiency, or a combination of both, the perfect electric crate motor is out there waiting for you.

Don’t let analysis paralysis hold you back! Take all this newfound knowledge, trust your gut, and get ready to transform your ride. The possibilities are endless, and the thrill of a silent, powerful electric machine is just around the corner. Embrace the challenge, get wrenching, and show the world what you can create with one of the best electric crate motors. Go make some electrifying history!

Leave a Comment