Best modems with router for Xfinity: Supercharge your internet

Remember that time your internet went down right in the middle of that crucial video call? Or when you were trying to stream your favorite show and it kept buffering every two minutes? We’ve all been there, silently cursing our internet provider and the mysterious box that’s supposed to keep us connected. If you’re an Xfinity customer, chances are you’re paying a rental fee for their modem and router. But what if you could ditch that monthly charge, boost your internet speed, and have more control over your home network? Finding the best modems with router for Xfinity can be overwhelming, but that’s where we come in!

We’ve put together a comprehensive guide, packed with reviews and helpful tips, to help you navigate the world of modem-router combos. Think of us as your friendly neighborhood tech gurus, here to demystify the jargon and guide you toward the perfect device for your needs. No more frustrating lag, no more unnecessary fees – just smooth, reliable internet access so you can binge-watch, work from home, and video chat to your heart’s content. Let’s dive in and find the best modems with router for Xfinity that will transform your internet experience.

Before we jump into the best modems with router for xfinity review, let’s take a look at these Amazon products:

Last update on 2025-05-04 / Affiliate links / #CommissionsEarned / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Finding Your Perfect Match: The Quest for the Best Modems with Router for Xfinity

Ever feel like you’re throwing money at your internet bill each month, only to be greeted by buffering screens and dropped video calls? You’re not alone! For years, many of us have been renting our modems and routers directly from Xfinity. It seems convenient, but those monthly fees really add up. In fact, the average rental fee is around $14-$15 per month, which can easily total over $150 a year! That’s money you could be spending on, well, anything else.

That’s where purchasing your own modem and router combo comes in – and choosing one of the best modems with router for Xfinity can be a game-changer. Not only do you ditch the rental fees, but you can also potentially upgrade your internet performance. The latest models offer improved Wi-Fi speeds, wider coverage, and more robust security features. Think of it as giving your home network a serious boost.

Now, diving into the world of modems and routers can feel a little overwhelming. There are so many acronyms and technical specifications! DOCSIS 3.1, Wi-Fi 6, gigabit speeds – it’s enough to make your head spin. But don’t worry, we’re here to break it all down in plain English.

Think of this guide as your friendly companion on the journey to finding the perfect modem-router combo. We’ll walk you through the key factors to consider, highlight some of the top contenders, and help you make an informed decision. By the end, you’ll be well-equipped to choose one of the best modems with router for Xfinity and finally say goodbye to those pesky rental fees!

5 Best Modems With Router For Xfinity

NETGEAR Nighthawk CAX80

The NETGEAR Nighthawk CAX80 is a powerhouse for anyone needing top-tier performance. This modem-router combo supports the fastest Xfinity internet plans with ease, thanks to its DOCSIS 3.1 technology. Think blazing-fast downloads, buffer-free streaming, and lag-free gaming, all at the same time. Plus, its Wi-Fi 6 capabilities ensure a strong, reliable connection for all your devices, even in a crowded household. It’s definitely an investment, but one that pays off if you demand the best and are tired of renting equipment from Xfinity.

Beyond speed, the CAX80 offers impressive range and coverage. Its advanced antenna design spreads the Wi-Fi signal far and wide, eliminating dead zones and keeping you connected throughout your home. The intuitive NETGEAR app simplifies setup and management, allowing you to monitor your network, control access, and even run speed tests. While the price tag might make some balk, the CAX80’s performance and features make it a worthwhile consideration for serious internet users.

ARRIS SURFboard G36

The ARRIS SURFboard G36 is a strong contender for those who want a high-performance modem-router without breaking the bank. This device supports DOCSIS 3.1, meaning it can handle Xfinity’s Gigabit internet plans without a sweat. You can expect consistently fast speeds for streaming, gaming, and working from home. Setting up is a breeze with the SURFboard app, and the built-in Wi-Fi 6 technology provides a stable and reliable connection for multiple devices.

What makes the G36 particularly appealing is its balance of performance and value. It delivers impressive speeds and features that rival more expensive models, while remaining surprisingly affordable. The robust security features help keep your network safe, and the easy-to-use interface makes managing your network a piece of cake. If you’re looking to upgrade your Xfinity setup without emptying your wallet, the ARRIS SURFboard G36 is a solid choice.

Motorola MG8725

The Motorola MG8725 offers a compelling blend of performance, features, and affordability, making it a great all-around choice. It’s DOCSIS 3.1 compatible, ready to handle even the faster Xfinity internet tiers. Users can expect speedy downloads, seamless streaming, and smooth online gaming. Moreover, it’s equipped with Wi-Fi 5, which still provides excellent speeds and coverage for most homes, making it a significant upgrade for many.

The MG8725 really shines when it comes to ease of use. Setting it up is a cinch, and the intuitive web interface allows for effortless management of your network. You can easily monitor your bandwidth usage, set up parental controls, and manage connected devices. The inclusion of four Gigabit Ethernet ports provides plenty of options for connecting wired devices as well. The MG8725 is a very safe bet.

TP-Link Archer GX90

The TP-Link Archer GX90 is designed for gamers and bandwidth-heavy users. It’s a powerful modem-router combo that supports DOCSIS 3.1 and offers Wi-Fi 6 capabilities for lightning-fast wireless speeds. It’s perfect for handling demanding tasks like 4K streaming, online gaming, and large file transfers without any hiccups. The GX90 boasts impressive range and coverage, ensuring a strong, stable connection throughout your entire home.

What sets the Archer GX90 apart is its focus on gaming. It features a dedicated gaming band to prioritize gaming traffic, minimizing lag and maximizing performance. The sleek design and customizable lighting add a touch of style to your gaming setup. The TP-Link Tether app makes setup and management a breeze. If you’re a serious gamer looking for a modem-router that can keep up with your demands, the Archer GX90 is worth considering.

ARRIS SURFboard G34

The ARRIS SURFboard G34 delivers a reliable and consistent internet experience, making it a solid choice for most Xfinity customers. It supports DOCSIS 3.1, ensuring compatibility with Xfinity’s Gigabit internet plans, offering ample bandwidth for streaming, browsing, and working from home. The built-in Wi-Fi 6 technology provides a strong and stable connection for multiple devices, so everyone in your household can enjoy seamless online experiences.

The G34 offers a good balance of features and performance at a reasonable price. Setting it up is simple with the SURFboard app, and the interface is easy to navigate. The device offers ample security features to protect your network from threats. While it may not have all the bells and whistles of some of the higher-end models, the ARRIS SURFboard G34 is a dependable and affordable option that will deliver a solid internet connection.

Why Do People Need to Buy Modems with Routers for Xfinity?

Imagine your Xfinity internet service as a super-fast water pipe bringing the internet straight to your house. The modem acts like the faucet that connects this pipe to your home’s plumbing, while the router is the intricate network of pipes that distributes that water to different faucets (devices) throughout your house – your laptop, TV, phone, and even your smart fridge. Xfinity provides the main pipe (internet service), but you need your own faucet and plumbing (modem and router) to actually use it properly. They offer equipment rentals, but those rental fees can add up significantly over time. Owning your own modem and router combination eliminates these ongoing costs, saving you money month after month.

Think about those times you’re streaming a movie on your smart TV in the living room while your partner is on a video call in the home office, and your kids are gaming upstairs. Without a good modem and router, especially one specifically optimized for Xfinity, you might experience buffering, lag, or dropped connections. The best modems with routers for Xfinity are designed to handle high internet speeds and multiple devices simultaneously, ensuring a smooth and reliable online experience for everyone in your household. They can also future-proof your network as your internet needs evolve.

Furthermore, many Xfinity-approved modem and router combos come with advanced features that can significantly improve your online experience. Features like parental controls allow you to manage internet access for your kids, guest networks enable you to provide secure Wi-Fi access to visitors without compromising your personal network, and enhanced security protocols protect your devices from online threats. These aren’t always standard features on rental equipment, giving you more control and customization over your home network.

Ultimately, investing in one of the best modems with routers for Xfinity isn’t just about saving money; it’s about investing in a faster, more reliable, and more secure internet experience for your entire family. It’s about taking control of your home network and ensuring that you’re getting the most out of your Xfinity internet service. It’s a one-time investment that pays off in dividends with seamless streaming, lag-free gaming, and peace of mind knowing your home network is protected.

Understanding Xfinity Compatibility and Approved Lists

So, you’re venturing into the world of modem-router combos for Xfinity. Smart move! But before you dive headfirst into specs and features, let’s talk compatibility. Xfinity, like most ISPs, keeps a list of approved devices. This list is your best friend. Using a modem or router not on that list could mean connection issues, slower speeds, or even complete service denial. Think of it like trying to use a key that doesn’t fit the lock – frustrating and ultimately useless.

Why do they do this? Well, Xfinity needs to ensure that the modems and routers connecting to their network meet certain standards. This helps maintain network stability and security for everyone. It also allows them to offer the speeds they advertise. A faulty or incompatible modem could bottleneck your connection, preventing you from fully enjoying that blazing-fast internet you’re paying for.

Before you even begin shopping, head over to the Xfinity website and locate their list of approved modems and routers. The list is usually categorized by speed tiers, so find the section that corresponds to your Xfinity plan. Take a screenshot or bookmark the page. This will be your reference point throughout your search. Trust me, it will save you a lot of headaches down the road.

Think of this list as a curated selection of devices that Xfinity has vetted to work seamlessly with their service. While there might be other modems and routers out there that could potentially work, sticking to the approved list is the safest bet. It’s the difference between a guaranteed smooth experience and a potentially frustrating troubleshooting session with customer support.

Optimizing Your Home Network Setup for Peak Performance

Okay, you’ve got your shiny new modem-router combo. Time to plug it in and enjoy, right? Well, almost. The location of your device can significantly impact your Wi-Fi coverage and overall network performance. Tucking it away in a closet or behind a pile of books might seem convenient, but it’s a recipe for weak signals and dead spots. Imagine trying to have a video call while balancing on one foot – not exactly ideal.

Instead, aim for a central, elevated location. This allows the Wi-Fi signal to radiate outward in all directions, reaching more corners of your home. Keep it away from thick walls, metal objects, and other electronics that can interfere with the signal. Think of your modem-router as a lighthouse, broadcasting a signal to all your devices. You want to give it the best possible vantage point.

Don’t forget about your neighbors’ Wi-Fi networks. Too many overlapping signals can cause congestion and slow down your speeds. Use a Wi-Fi analyzer app on your smartphone or laptop to identify the least congested channels in your area. Then, access your router’s settings and manually select those channels. It’s like finding a less crowded lane on the highway, allowing your data to flow more freely.

Finally, consider the number of devices connected to your network. Each device consumes bandwidth, and too many devices can strain your router’s capabilities. If you have a large household with multiple users streaming videos, playing online games, and downloading files simultaneously, you might need a more powerful router with advanced features like Quality of Service (QoS) to prioritize certain types of traffic. It’s like having a traffic cop directing the flow of data to ensure everyone gets their fair share.

Security Considerations: Protecting Your Data and Privacy

Your home network is essentially the gateway to your digital life. It’s where you connect all your devices, access sensitive information, and conduct online transactions. Therefore, securing your network is paramount. Leaving your modem-router with default settings and weak passwords is like leaving your front door unlocked – inviting trouble in. Think of it as protecting your digital valuables.

Start by changing the default username and password for your router’s admin interface. These are often printed on a sticker on the device itself. Using the default credentials is a major security risk, as hackers can easily access them. Choose a strong password that’s difficult to guess, using a combination of upper and lowercase letters, numbers, and symbols. It’s like creating a complex lock for your digital safe.

Enable Wi-Fi encryption using WPA3, if your router and devices support it. WPA3 is the latest and most secure encryption protocol, providing stronger protection against unauthorized access. If WPA3 isn’t available, use WPA2 with AES encryption. Avoid older protocols like WEP, which are easily cracked. It’s like upgrading from a simple deadbolt to a high-security lock with multiple tumblers.

Consider enabling the firewall on your router. A firewall acts as a barrier between your network and the outside world, blocking unauthorized traffic and preventing malicious attacks. Keep your router’s firmware up to date. Manufacturers regularly release firmware updates to patch security vulnerabilities and improve performance. Regularly updating is like getting regular checkups for your digital immune system, ensuring it’s protected against the latest threats.

Troubleshooting Common Modem-Router Issues

Let’s face it, even the best modem-router combos can occasionally encounter problems. A dropped connection, slow speeds, or a complete outage can be incredibly frustrating. But don’t panic! Most issues can be resolved with a little troubleshooting. Think of it as being your own IT support.

The first and often most effective solution is the classic “power cycle.” Unplug your modem-router from the power outlet, wait 30 seconds, and then plug it back in. This allows the device to reset and clear any temporary glitches. It’s like giving your computer a reboot – often surprisingly effective.

If power cycling doesn’t work, check the cables connecting your modem-router to the wall outlet and your devices. Ensure that they are securely plugged in and not damaged. A loose or faulty cable can cause intermittent connectivity issues. It’s like making sure the gas line to your stove is properly connected – essential for things to work smoothly.

If you’re experiencing slow speeds, run a speed test using a reputable online tool. Compare the results to the speeds you’re paying for from Xfinity. If the speeds are significantly lower, contact Xfinity customer support to report the issue. They may need to troubleshoot the connection from their end. It’s like checking your car’s speedometer to make sure it’s reading accurately.

Finally, if you’ve tried everything else and your modem-router still isn’t working properly, consider resetting it to factory defaults. This will erase all your custom settings and restore the device to its original state. Consult your router’s manual for instructions on how to perform a factory reset. However, be warned that this will require you to reconfigure your Wi-Fi network and other settings. It’s like hitting the reset button on your brain – a last resort, but sometimes necessary.

Your Guide to Finding the Best Modems With Router For Xfinity

Hey there! Getting ready to upgrade your internet setup? That’s awesome! Dealing with Xfinity can be a bit…unique, especially when it comes to your equipment. Renting their modem and router might seem easy, but trust me, buying your own can save you serious money in the long run and even boost your internet performance.

This guide is here to help you navigate the world of modems with built-in routers that are compatible with Xfinity. Think of it as your friendly, tech-savvy pal giving you the lowdown on everything you need to know before you click “buy.” We’ll walk through the important stuff without getting too technical, so you can confidently choose the perfect modem/router combo for your needs. Let’s dive in and find the best modems with router for Xfinity!

1. DOCSIS Standard: Understanding the Need for Speed

Okay, first things first: DOCSIS. This stands for Data Over Cable Service Interface Specification. It’s basically the technology that allows data to travel over the cable lines. The higher the DOCSIS version, the faster the potential speeds. Xfinity is constantly upgrading their network, so you want a modem/router that can keep up. Right now, DOCSIS 3.1 is the gold standard.

Think of it like this: DOCSIS 3.0 is like a two-lane highway, while DOCSIS 3.1 is a superhighway with tons of lanes. You wouldn’t want to drive a Ferrari on a dirt road, would you? Similarly, a DOCSIS 3.0 modem/router might be compatible, but it’ll likely bottleneck your speeds if you’re paying for a high-speed Xfinity plan. If you want to future-proof your setup and get the most out of your internet, opt for DOCSIS 3.1. When shopping for the best modems with router for Xfinity, this is one of the most important considerations!

2. Speed Compatibility: Matching Your Plan to Your Modem

So, you know about DOCSIS, but what about the actual speeds? Xfinity offers various internet plans, from basic to ultra-fast. Your modem/router needs to be able to handle the speeds you’re paying for. Don’t buy a modem rated for 400 Mbps if you’re on a 1 Gig plan! That’s like trying to drink a gallon of water through a straw.

Check your Xfinity bill or online account to see your current internet plan’s speed. Then, look for a modem/router that supports at least that speed, ideally with a bit of headroom for future upgrades. For example, if you have a 600 Mbps plan, a modem/router rated for 1 Gbps (1000 Mbps) or higher would be a good choice. This will ensure you’re getting the full speeds you’re paying for and won’t need to upgrade again anytime soon. Finding the best modems with router for Xfinity also means finding the perfect speed that matches your Internet plan.

3. Router Capabilities: Wi-Fi Standards and Range

The router part of your modem/router combo is responsible for creating your Wi-Fi network. This is what allows your phones, laptops, and smart TVs to connect to the internet wirelessly. Important factors here include Wi-Fi standards (like Wi-Fi 5 or Wi-Fi 6) and range. Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) is the newest standard and offers faster speeds and better performance, especially in homes with many connected devices.

Consider the size and layout of your home. A small apartment might only need a basic router with decent range, while a larger house with multiple floors might require a more powerful router or even a mesh Wi-Fi system. Look for routers with features like MU-MIMO (Multi-User, Multiple-Input, Multiple-Output), which allows the router to communicate with multiple devices simultaneously, improving overall network performance. Think about how many devices you have connected at the same time. This will help you choose a router that can handle the load without slowing down your internet. When hunting for the best modems with router for Xfinity, don’t forget to consider what your Wi-Fi needs are in your home.

4. Channel Bonding: Understanding the Importance of More Channels

Channel bonding is a crucial aspect of modem performance that often goes unnoticed. In simple terms, it refers to a modem’s ability to combine multiple channels to transmit and receive data. The more channels a modem can bond, the faster and more reliable your internet connection will be. Think of it like adding more lanes to a highway – more lanes mean less congestion and smoother traffic flow.

With DOCSIS 3.1 modems, look for models that support a high number of downstream and upstream channels. This is especially important if you have a high-speed internet plan or multiple devices streaming or gaming simultaneously. A modem with fewer channels may struggle to keep up with the demand, resulting in slower speeds and buffering issues. Don’t skimp on this – a modem with ample channel bonding capabilities will provide a much smoother and more consistent internet experience. Selecting the best modems with router for Xfinity includes prioritizing a modem with high channel bonding to ensure optimal performance.

5. Voice Compatibility: If You Use Xfinity Voice

Do you use Xfinity Voice (their phone service)? If so, you’ll need a modem/router combo that specifically supports voice functionality. Not all modems with routers include this feature, so it’s crucial to double-check before you buy. Voice-compatible modems will have phone ports (usually labeled “Tel 1” and “Tel 2”) on the back.

These modems are often referred to as eMTA (Embedded Multimedia Terminal Adapter) devices. They convert the digital signal from your Xfinity internet connection into an analog signal that can be used by your traditional phone. If you don’t have Xfinity Voice, you can skip this consideration. However, if you rely on your landline for calls, emergencies, or other reasons, make sure the modem/router you choose is compatible with Xfinity Voice. The best modems with router for Xfinity for you will include this if you use Xfinity Voice.

6. Budget and Long-Term Savings: Investing Wisely

Let’s talk money! Buying your own modem/router requires an upfront investment, but it can save you a significant amount in the long run. Xfinity charges a monthly rental fee for their equipment, which can quickly add up over time. Do the math to see how long it will take for your purchase to pay for itself.

Consider the total cost of ownership, including the purchase price, potential maintenance (although modems/routers are generally reliable), and the savings on monthly rental fees. A more expensive modem/router with better features and performance might be a worthwhile investment if it provides a superior internet experience and lasts for several years. Don’t just go for the cheapest option – consider the long-term value and potential savings. Finding the best modems with router for Xfinity means finding a balance between initial cost and long-term savings.

7. Customer Reviews and Expert Opinions: Doing Your Research

Before you make a final decision, take some time to read customer reviews and expert opinions on the modem/router you’re considering. Online retailers like Amazon, Best Buy, and Newegg often have detailed reviews from real users who have experience with the product. Look for reviews that mention compatibility with Xfinity, speed performance, and reliability.

Also, check out tech websites and publications that offer expert reviews and comparisons of different modems and routers. These reviews can provide valuable insights into the strengths and weaknesses of each product and help you make an informed decision. Pay attention to both positive and negative feedback, and try to get a balanced perspective. Remember, everyone’s experience is different, but reading reviews can give you a good idea of what to expect. The best modems with router for Xfinity will have positive feedback from customers and experts alike.

FAQ

Can I really save money by buying my own modem and router combo?

Absolutely! Renting equipment from Xfinity might seem convenient at first, but those monthly fees can really add up over time. When you purchase your own modem and router combo, you’re making a one-time investment that will pay for itself within a year or two. Think of all the things you could do with that extra cash each month – a nice dinner, a weekend getaway, or even just putting it towards your savings!

Beyond the immediate cost savings, owning your equipment gives you more control. You’re not locked into Xfinity’s choices, and you can select a model that best suits your specific needs and budget. Plus, if you ever decide to switch providers, you can take your modem and router combo with you. It’s truly an investment in your internet future!

How do I know if a modem and router combo is compatible with my Xfinity plan?

This is a super important question! The key is to check Xfinity’s list of approved devices. They keep an updated list on their website that shows which modems and routers are certified to work with their service at different speed tiers. You’ll want to find the list that specifies compatible “modem-router combo” devices, not just individual modems.

Make sure the modem and router combo you’re considering supports the maximum speeds of your Xfinity internet plan. Getting one that’s underpowered could lead to slow speeds and frustrating lag. If you’re unsure, it’s always best to contact Xfinity customer support or check their website. Better safe than sorry!

What’s the difference between DOCSIS 3.0 and DOCSIS 3.1, and which one should I choose?

DOCSIS (Data Over Cable Service Interface Specification) is basically the technology that allows your modem to communicate with Xfinity’s network. DOCSIS 3.1 is the newer, more advanced version of DOCSIS 3.0. The main difference is speed. DOCSIS 3.1 can handle significantly faster internet speeds than DOCSIS 3.0.

While DOCSIS 3.0 modems and router combos may be less expensive initially, DOCSIS 3.1 is definitely the way to go, especially if you’re planning on upgrading your internet speed in the future, or already have a faster plan. It’s more future-proof and will provide a better overall experience. If your Xfinity plan is above, say, 300 Mbps, definitely choose a DOCSIS 3.1 modem and router combo.

Are modem and router combos as good as separate modems and routers?

Generally speaking, separate modems and routers can offer more flexibility and performance, especially if you’re a serious gamer or have a large home with many devices connected. You can choose high-end components optimized for specific tasks and upgrade them independently.

However, for most users, a quality modem and router combo provides a perfectly adequate and convenient solution. They simplify setup, reduce clutter, and are often more cost-effective. Plus, they still offer decent performance for everyday tasks like browsing, streaming, and video conferencing. Think of it as choosing between a sports car and a reliable sedan – both will get you where you need to go, but one is optimized for speed and handling while the other is great for practicality.

How difficult is it to set up a new modem and router combo?

Don’t worry, it’s usually not as daunting as it sounds! Most modem and router combos come with pretty straightforward instructions, and the process is generally similar across different brands. Typically, you’ll connect the modem to your cable outlet, plug in the power adapter, and then connect your computer or laptop directly to the device with an ethernet cable.

Then, you’ll usually be directed to a setup page through a web browser. From there, you will follow the on-screen instructions and might need to provide some information like your Xfinity account number or the modem’s MAC address (which is usually found on a sticker on the device). Once everything is connected, you’ll call Xfinity to activate the new device and have them remove your old one from your account. There are helpful videos online if you get stuck!

What happens if my modem and router combo breaks down?

This is a valid concern! If you rent equipment from Xfinity, they’ll usually replace it for free if it malfunctions. However, when you own your device, you’re responsible for any repairs or replacements. That’s why it’s important to choose a reputable brand with a good warranty.

Before you panic and buy a new one, double-check the warranty! Many manufacturers offer warranties for one or two years, and some even longer. If the device is still under warranty, you can usually get it repaired or replaced for free. Also, don’t forget the basics – check the power supply, all the cables, and even try a simple reset. These are often the culprits.

Will buying a new modem and router combo really improve my internet speed?

It depends! If you’re currently using an older modem and router that’s not compatible with your Xfinity plan’s speed or if you are still using Xfinity’s rented equipment, then upgrading to a newer, compatible modem and router combo can definitely improve your internet speed. A newer DOCSIS standard will handle faster speeds and more devices than older technology.

However, keep in mind that the modem and router combo is only one piece of the puzzle. Other factors can also affect your internet speed, like the quality of your wiring, the number of devices connected to your network, and even Xfinity’s network performance in your area. Upgrading your equipment is a great first step, but don’t expect miracles if there are other bottlenecks.

Conclusion

So, there you have it! Navigating the world of internet connectivity can feel like deciphering a secret code, but hopefully, this guide to the best modems with router for Xfinity has made things a little clearer. Armed with this information, you’re now well-equipped to ditch those rental fees and take control of your home network. Think of all the things you can do with that extra money! Faster speeds, smoother streaming, and reliable connections – it’s all within your reach.

Now it’s time to take the plunge! Don’t let decision paralysis hold you back. Revisit the reviews, weigh your priorities, and trust your gut. Whether you opt for lightning-fast speeds or rock-solid reliability, remember you’re upgrading your digital life. Go forth and conquer the internet, knowing you’ve made an informed and empowered choice. Your perfect Xfinity experience awaits!

Leave a Comment